Seasons
Click on a season to view this team's summary of that season. Note that win/loss/draw records are based on regular season matches only. Asterisk (*) next to crowd figure denotes not all home crowd figures were available for corresponding season.
| Competition | Name | Position | Extra Info | W | L | D | Pts For | Pts Ag. | Att % | Def % | Coach | Top Tryscorer(s) | Top Pointscorer(s) | Home Venue(s) | Crowd Avg |
|---|
| Second Division 1981/82 | Carlisle | 2nd | | 28 | 4 | 0 | 649 | 296 | 134.73% | 61.45% | Allan AGAR | 23 | - | Mick MORGAN | 232 | - | Stephen FERRES | Brunton Park | 3,087 |
| Championship 1982/83 | Carlisle | 16th | Wooden Spoon | 2 | 28 | 0 | 252 | 751 | 57.93% | 172.64% | Mick MORGAN, John ATKINSON | 11 | - | Wally YOUNGMAN, Dean BELL | 45 | - | Andy NEWTON | Brunton Park | 2,170 |
| Second Division 1983/84 | Carlisle | 15th | | 12 | 22 | 0 | 539 | 780 | 85.06% | 123.09% | John ATKINSON | 20 | - | Gary PEACHAM | 80 | - | Gary PEACHAM | Brunton Park | 875 |
| Second Division 1984/85 | Carlisle | 5th | | 18 | 10 | 0 | 547 | 437 | 109.69% | 87.63% | John ATKINSON | 24 | - | Gary PEACHAM | 112 | - | Dean CARROLL | Brunton Park | 1,001 |
| Second Division 1985/86 | Carlisle | 11th | | 15 | 17 | 2 | 585 | 682 | 90.32% | 105.30% | - | 18 | - | Gary PEACHAM, Kevin PAPE | 158 | - | Dean CARROLL | Brunton Park | 618 |
| Second Division 1986/87 | Carlisle | 8th | | 15 | 12 | 1 | 463 | 446 | 95.33% | 91.83% | Roy LESTER | 17 | - | Kevin PAPE | 74 | - | Brian TUNSTALL | Brunton Park (14), Southend Road (2) | 758 |
| Second Division 1987/88 | Carlisle | 11th | | 14 | 13 | 1 | 388 | 446 | 84.52% | 97.16% | - | 19 | - | Kevin PAPE | 82 | - | Brian TUNSTALL | Brunton Park | 843 |
| Second Division 1988/89 | Carlisle | 11th | | 14 | 13 | 1 | 512 | 441 | 96.73% | 83.32% | Roy LESTER, Tommy DAWES | 13 | - | Kevin PAPE | 163 | - | Barry VICKERS | Gillford Park | 675 |
| Second Division 1989/90 | Carlisle | 17th | | 9 | 19 | 0 | 511 | 625 | 93.47% | 114.32% | - | 16 | - | Kevin PAPE | 155 | - | Barry VICKERS | Gillford Park | 574 |
| Second Division 1990/91 | Carlisle | 8th | | 16 | 10 | 2 | 613 | 425 | 121.49% | 84.23% | Cameron BELL | 17 | - | Kevin PAPE | 170 | - | Barry VICKERS | Gillford Park | 946 |
| Second Division 1991/92 | Carlisle | 6th | | 12 | 15 | 1 | 490 | 466 | 93.87% | 89.27% | - | 15 | - | Clayton FRIEND | 103 | - | Barry VICKERS | Gillford Park | 881 |
| Second Division 1992/93 | Carlisle | 7th | | 6 | 19 | 3 | 454 | 721 | 77.89% | 123.70% | Cameron BELL | 16 | - | Kevin PAPE | 66 | - | Kevin BETHWAITE | Gillford Park | 638 |
| Second Division 1993/94 | Carlisle | 13th | | 9 | 21 | 0 | 540 | 878 | 86.44% | 140.55% | - | 20 | - | Kevin PAPE | 166 | - | Willie RICHARDSON | Gillford Park | 678 |
| Second Division 1994/95 | Carlisle | 14th | | 8 | 22 | 0 | 546 | 877 | 81.11% | 130.28% | Hugh WADDELL, Paul CHARLTON | 14 | - | Danny RUSSELL | 180 | - | Willie RICHARDSON | Gillford Park (18), Gateshead (1) | 366 |
| Second Division 1995/96 | Carlisle | 5th | | 12 | 8 | 0 | 600 | 309 | 130.02% | 66.96% | - | 12 | - | Gary RUDDY, Stuart RHODES | 180 | - | Willie RICHARDSON | Gillford Park (9), Warwick Road (3) | 520 |
| Second Division 1996 | Carlisle | 4th | | 13 | 9 | 0 | 654 | 486 | 118.59% | 88.12% | Paul CHARLTON | 17 | - | Danny RUSSELL | 236 | - | Willie RICHARDSON | Gillford Park | 587 |
| Second Division 1997 | Carlisle | 5th | | 13 | 7 | 0 | 564 | 384 | 116.86% | 79.56% | Paul CHARLTON | 22 | - | Gary RUDDY, Darryl MENZIES | 155 | - | Willie RICHARDSON | Gillford Park | 480 |
